woensdag 27 mei 2015

PhD progress Cities, Europe

Title: Bad, ugly, green, professionals, cities, Europe

Green, meaning the plants, vegetation, trees etc.

Cities.
It is impossible, even for me, to do research on all the cities in Europe. I have three more years to go. The professor and I agreed on that, last January.

Which arguments do I need to introduce, to select, in a week time, three or four cities.

Political correct argument anno 2015 in the Netherlands is 'diversity'.

Diversity? On scale, on age, on geographical siting, on economical situation, language, spatial patterns, on green, on professionals, on beauty (tourist visitor figure), on 'bad' (criminal activities). These are the relevant topics for my research. Is it complete? Did I not mention an important issue, like 'frist things first', probably also typical European.

Where to begin? (Scenario thinking)

Scenario one.

Suppose Lisbon is a city candidate, because it is a city in Europe, timed in the early modern world, containing professionals with a pioneering spirit. 'Only in the seventeenth century, with the increasing exodus of New Christian merchant families, was it overtaken by Amsterdam and London' ( J.J Norwich ed., M. Newitt, The great cities in history, (2009) p.156-158. Personally, when I look at the plan of Lisbon (16th century, Civitates Orbis Terrarum) in this book, something really intriges me. I do not know what exactly, but I feel a need to find out.

When I have enough arguments to choose Lisbon, all other coastel cities in West Europe can be excluded. Question is, can all southern cities be excluded as well? The consequence will be to draw a diagonal line from south-west to the north-east of Europe.

I hear my stomach. I take some time out. See you soon......

dinsdag 26 mei 2015

PhD progress Perfect counterparts, scenario's

The worktitle 'good, bad, ugly', is derived from the title of the film 'the good, the bad, the ugly', directed by Sergio Leone, in the beginning of the sixties, twentieth century. The film has been categorized as a Western, a spaghetti western, if you please. The main characters are men. The plot is to find the pot of gold. This gold is buried somewhere. In the beginning only one person knows where. This person is about to die. Angel eyes (Mr. Bad,  most of us presume) shoots this one with the money knowledge to death, after having extracted information from him. The presumed Good, sometimes almost femininely shot ( an expression used by filmers) also finds the place of gold, with the little help of Mr. Ugly. So far the front 'office'. As a back 'office' , the civil war in the States has been pictured. A desert, some wooden houses, a bridge, village people, horses, guns, mountains, hardly water,  a Father, a woman, and a lot of war men.

So far this script. 1961, Italian director, American actors, location shots in Spain. The money grail.

Why on earth did I selected this script out if the million of scripts passing by and celebrated in Cannes (South of France), every year again?
I do not know precisely, but by doing history now, I am trying to find out.

Does green has anything to do with pink? With purple? With blue? With red and white? With grey?
The writer of The pink pagode....... introduced thirtysix scenario's. Easily interpretated as a patriarchic (or is it patriarchale?) approach.  Isn't it? PABO pappa? (just Dutch kidding). It seems not done in doing history to have pink glasses on. But really, isn't it all in the game?

At least, I am not going to avoid complexity. I am not going to keep it simple. For the one and only
reason: it isn't simple. So, I am not going to pretend it is. Clear cut.

What I learned from doing history nowadays, it is all about facts. As a former math girl, I definitely have a way with that. But, math people are also aiming at the perfect match. Which, in history has another meaning. What is perfect to do in history is to take a look at the other side as well. To counter.

So, there are the subject and objects and there are the coutersubject and counterobjects. Therefore, because I am doing history, implicates this. In the meantime I feel the need to schorten my worktitle. In doing history, naming Good, implies also to study Bad. What to do with Ugly, then? To go ahead with countering, I may be better name it Beauty. Beauty, now, will attract more persons curious to my future writings and Beauty is the counter of Ugly. Isn't it? (Reasonable doubt)

What is it going to be? (Scenario thinking)
Good, Ugly
Good, Beauty
Bad, Ugly
Bad, Beauty

As I will procede in my next blog.

maandag 25 mei 2015

PhD progress Choices

PhD worktitle: Good, bad, ugly
PhD subject: Green, professionals and the city
Field: History
Time demarcation: 1800-1810, 1900-1910, 2000-2010
Space demarcation: Europe

In front: the political, the linguistic, the spatial
In back: the social, the technical, the economical, the material, the visual, the biological

Questions
How come some professionals think there is not enough green in the city.
How come some professionals think the city is green enough
How come some professionals do not think of green at all?
How come there is a growing amount of attention on green and the city, today?

Intellectual framework, under consideration
1. G.E. Andela, J.E. Bosma, Groene stedebouw 1900-2000,( 2006), p.582-598, Bouwen in Nederland 600-2000, ed. J.E. Bosma, A. Mekking, K. Ottenheym, A. van der Woud
2. M. Niemi, Politicians, professionals and publics: conflicts over green space in Helsinki, C. 1950-2000, (2006), p.207-228, The European city and green space, ed. P. Clark.
3. U.N., W.C.E.D report, 'Our common future', chapter nine ' The urban challenge', (1989).

Notes about accesibility of the to be chosen literature
1. In Dutch, printed published, text not available on internet
2. In English, printed published, text not available on internet
3. In English, text available on internet

zaterdag 23 mei 2015

PhD progress History, we have a problem

 In written thinking on the subject of 'green', meaning plants, vegetation, there is a serious historical problem

Is there any political writing on thinking 'green', thinking 'plants', thinking 'vegetation' ?
Are there any philosophical writings on the same thinking?
Has any biologist ever written on this subject of thinking?

Suppose, my subject in this historical research is head of this. What would that mean for doing history? For the historical research method?

No more intellectual frameworks?

Fortunately for me, when I was attending my first symposium in the field of history, september 2012, Rotterdam, the Netherlands. All invited speakers were sixty years of age or older. They agreed on one thing. They said to us, a much younger audience: 'Don't do the same as we did'.


Uh?

Meaning what?

Subjects?
Time demarcations?
Space demarcations?
Method, perhaps?


Nobody paid attention at this, then. But now, I think it is becoming important. To change the way history is done or written.

vrijdag 22 mei 2015

PhD progress Green thinking

I know, yesterday I promised to shine my light on the writings and sayings of Peter Sloterdijk.

 I changed my mind.
But you are free to view the Peter Sloterdijk youtubes yourselves. I can say it is entertaining. I think of Peter as a nice person to listen to.

When the subject of my PhD is green, outdoor space and cities in Europe. I have to start to investigate 'green thinking'. Not meaning 'sustainable ' or 'environmental' thinking, but ' plant ' thinking, or 'vegetation' thinking or in a way 'flora' thinking.

Well, has anybody in the past done such a thing?


donderdag 21 mei 2015

PhD progress What kind of historian do I want to be?

PhD title: Good, bad, ugly
PhD working subject: Green, architecture, cities.
Field : History
Time demarcations: Beginning of nineteenth century, beginning of twentieth century, beginning of twenty-first century.
Space demarcation: Europe


For writing history on an academic level one is expected to follow four phases:
1. Prepare
2. Structure
3. Formulate
4. Make corrections

I am in phase one, at the beginning of phase two and I am trying a bit of phase three and four.
Right now, I am collecting information with which I can create my 'strars'. Green 'stars' as you would have understood by now or you will understand in time.
As soon as the 'stars' are made visible by me, it shall be possible to create 'stripes' between the 'stars'.
A 'Mijnske history universe' will be visible by then.
On top of this I have a warning. The ones who are afraid of space, of hights and or depths, should make sure they are prepared to dive or to fly before taking action. Reading all my stuff. One can also any time decide to stay on shore. You will be able to see the reflections of the 'stars and stripes' in the water. We are all free persons. And for the technically focussed humen I have the following advice:
try to find the on and off button as soon as possible.
You know what is good for you.

Phase two. The PhD writings has to contain approximately eighty thousand words.
This can be structured by chapters, aimed result: a printed book.
This can be structured by blogs, aimed result: readers all over the world, knowledge spread

What do I do, preparing?
1. I think and blog about the function, the aim and the target group.
2. I have chosen a relevant subject.
3. I am trying to formulate the central question. One I want to find answers for. Therefor I have to study literature to check if I can sustain my question.
4. I am looking for relevant information by reading literature, finding sources and interviewing.
Source: www.taalwinkel.nl    www.taalwinkel.nl

Well, I didn't answer the question 'What kind of historian do I want to be?', by now, did I?
I'll give it a try.
I do like to do all the points written above. What about my focus?
The subjects I am interested in have a broad spectrum. Most of them occur in contemporary times as well in times gone by. Today, and for more than four years already, I am very interested in the 'green' issue. It seems to concern us all, in the end. Add to this that I have been gifted with spatial capabilities, since I was ten. A talent not everybody is lucky to have inherited. I also have a talent for detecting beautiful, ugly and mediocre things. When one is not that esthetical like I am, my experience is that it is really hard to 'meet'. I also have a talent to absord loads and loads of information. Like a sponge. I need a lot of 'water'. My aim in life is to share this talents of mine with as much others as possible. Now, I think I am more talented than skilled at the moment. For writing
history one needs to be quite skilled and have a lot of energy as well. For being quite neutral a person, I hardly favour anything. So what Else to do? I had to find my rage ( thank you, Peter). It was quite hard for me to find my rage, my energy ( I looked at a few Peter Sloterdijk youtubes yesterday evening). I did find my rage, though, it is called 'injustice'.

I sincerely hope you have a little patience with me. I am trying with ups and downs to improve my writing skills, making my way into history. At the same time I really like to receive compliments. Please do not confuse compliments with complaints. I hate complaints.

And now and then I really like an intellectual challenge.......
I'll discuss 'Mensenpark', written by Peter Sloterdijk, 2000, next time.


woensdag 20 mei 2015

PhD progress Green architecture, where and what, images


In March and April 2014, I have systemstically searched on the internet via Google, looking for images. I found about fifty realised buildings, worldwide. In the Netherlands I found twent- six. About fifty percent of the total amount of buildings. What is going on in the Netherlands?

Are the Netherlands not green enough?
Are the Netherlands so desirably green, people / the public want to keep it that way?
Are there so many clients wanting a green covered or clad building?
Has green architecture become an instrument for city or regional marketing?
Is there a watermanagement or a heat problem in the cities?
Are other buildings too ugly, the public and or the clients say: no more!
Is it one of the many creative outcomes of the minds of architects?


A selection if the images will be published soon on this very blogspot page.